"It looks like we have lost face of Fudan University. "November 4, Shanghai foreign investment in the company's strategic development director Luo junzhang in Sina online to see a transfer from the Manager magazine Fudan MBA pay an average of 19 million on news, also from Fudan a colleague said. Subsequently, two person knowing and laughing.
Luo junzhang, Fudan MBA graduate from 2004. He illustrated the Bund "reporter said:" this story by pure nonsense, we ban most students now annual salary is around 10 million. ”
2 November, by the Manager magazine's "2004 China MBA business school ranking" opened, tsem won the first place, it Fudan Guanghua School of management, Peking University respectively second and third. Of these, Fudan MBA graduates starting salaries ranking the highest average annual salary of 19 million, more than tsem 14.6 million and pekinguniversity 13.1 million. Ranking by some students have feedback to Fudan University School of management, career development center acting director Wong Chi wing there. He told reporters that recently a lot of Fudan MBA students asked him the credibility of this data, when journalists are also asking the same question, he did not comment.
Then, the average annual salary of Fudan MBA "19 million" is how out of their real salary is probably?
"19 million annual salary" and "big bubble?"
According to the Manager magazine, they investigate the crowd is 2001 in Fudan MBA students. For this reason, reporter interviewed several days of Fudan MBA graduates.
2001 graduated from Fudan University International MBA class monitor Ho Hau de accepts this ranking survey, he is currently working for the public universal company. See the survey results, in his view salary data is high. He told reporters: "most business schools have their own student wages blowing very high, not very objective. ”
Currently working in Intel company pool-you said that the average annual salary of $ 19 is impossible. In 2001, he graduated from Fudan MBA at Intel, did not get the 19 million such high wages. He said, Fudan MBA students not multinational background, so basically can't get such a high salary, "in General, MBA graduates get wage and read MBA before working relationship. Read MBA and cannot bring to wage such a big change, generally is based on the original stable growth. ”
Pool-think this survey samples may be taken from a very special case. According to him the past few years in the company's experience in recruiting MBA graduates, General work 2-3 years after their MBA students, the annual salary of about 10 million.
Press again to Fudan University School of management, ask the attendant circumstances. The hospital and the Manager magazine had contact, but does not provide for the Manager magazine about MBA students pay data and information.
The Manager, editor in Chief: 80 per cent of Fudan MBA annual income there is no more than 19 000 people to be interviewed on the managers of the "average income of 190 000 annual salary," "average" two words of understanding, is the sum of all data divided by the number of data (the number of respondents) have value, which is the simple arithmetic average. But it really the case? the magazine editor in Chief, Mr. Yangjunjie to the Bund pictorial reporter email so explained: "the Manager" ranking list pay part to all graduates of the school starting salary of 80-bit values to calculate the average income, income of 80-bit values reflect the school graduates earned in high-end level, most embodies a college graduate salary of overall standards and future trends. Fudan MBA graduates of the first entry point that is 20 percent of the graduates to meet or exceed the annual salary of 19 million, and 80 per cent of the $ 19 million. ”
This is not what most people are familiar with the standard method of calculation of salary, reporter confused, repeatedly asked Yang editor-in-Chief: "if only 20 percent of the graduates achieve such a level, why the magazine still says ' the words ' average incomes? is there any suspicion of misleading readers?" on this, Mr. euphemism to recognize this yangjunjie secondary research exists some negligence, no notes on interpretation of statistical concepts, leading to many media to "Fudan MBA pay an average of 19 million" as its theme.
This time the Manager of the ranking is the first reference to "international conventions", initiated by third parties independent of the list. Is the Manager of the three case studies commissioned a global company, one of the Ipsos market research consulting survey of specific studies. Journalists have contacted Ipsos consulting company, the company is to "customers have asked, don't allow us to investigate the company accept any related interview" as an excuse to deny the interview. Lee even Broch education culture promotion agency (a China MBA research non-profit institutions) China operating Director Zhao Eagle view this list at home and doing better, but there is not enough. The biggest drawback is that the list of individual indicators no weight description, that is, the index on the index percentage is not clear. "A compelling research, you must first tell us his research methods. Otherwise it is not convincing. ”
In such a loss of rigorous investigation attitude, Fudan MBA salary 19 million "big bubble" were blown out.
"19 million annual salary," most of the following
Salary, a sensitive and stimulating conversation. In the interview, relative to 2001 graduate school sister, brother, later-Fudan MBA students willing to interview a much smaller proportion. Many people call themselves busy, or don't want to answer salary this sensitive issue refused interview. In 2004, Fudan MBA graduates in the biggest winner is the one to the HSBC student work, he got the annual income of 80 million RMB (Chinese employees enjoy GlobalPay and foreign employees the same salary standards, rather than by
According to the standard distribution of salary on the Mainland).In 2004-Fudan MBA graduates Luo junzhang and his colleagues, the majority of students also and they, in the hands of the pinch 10 million a year contract, also in professional managers in the fight of the workplace. Although it Fudan University MBA is, currently, they still belong to not get the 19 million annual salary of the majority of the Chinese working group.
No comments:
Post a Comment